Title header 


 

 

 

 

English Opera Interregnum
(1866-1876)

 

After the Royal English Opera went bankrupt in February 1866, there was a gap of 10 years without any major new English opera being staged, although one exception needs to be mentioned that of Balfe's The Talisman based on Sir Walter Scott's novel. It was an English opera unfinished on his death in 1870. It was completed by Michael Costa and staged at Drury Lane in June 11, 1874, but in Italian as Il Talismano. An English version was not given until 1891 in Liverpool by the Carl Rosa company [1].  However, the lack of new English operas did not mean that no English opera was performed. There was considerable activity, often down to touring companies playing a limited diet of popular continental opera in English and some established English operas from the English Romantic era. These included Mozart's Don Giovanni, Auber's Fra Diavolo, Gounod's Faust, Bellini's La sonnambula, Donizetti's Lucia di Lammermoor, Verdi's Il Trovatore, Balfe's The Bohemian Girl, Benedict's Lily of Killarney and Wallace's Maritana and Lurline.  Such conservatism was forced on companies by their precarious finances, which greatly discouraged taking risks on preparing a new opera. However, there were a considerable number of new, lighter musical works: short comic operas, operettas, burlesques and musicals,  which had a much more immediate appeal.

 

London

The English opera scene in London during this time was very fragmented with, for the most part, occasional short seasons of a week or two.  The Nottingham Daily Express (June 12, 1872) lamented "But where is English opera" in its survey of the various operatic happenings in London in 1872. Edward Tyrrell Smith, lessee of Astley's, planned an English opera season starting Easter, 1866. It began with Weber's Der Freischutz but then closed within around a month. On May 21, the soprano, Jenny Baur, opened at the Surrey Theatre with her company after which she joined with Charles Durand and toured the provinces. There was a plan for a season of English opera at Drury Lane but that came to nothing. Sadler's Wells staged two weeks in August 1867 and, in March 1868, Jenny Baur's company did a short season at the Standard Theatre.

1869 was more promising. George Perren organised a season lasting much of the second half of the year at Crystal Palace. By the October, 220,000 people were said to have attended them [2]. The Athenaeum (June 4, 1870), p. 749, wrote that "the Crystal Palace still continues to afford a refuge for English opera" and it continued to do so for a further five years, although the season length got shorter.  In May 1870, there was a week at Astley's and, in the autumn, the Gaiety put on a short season, which included Herold's Zampa.

1871 saw the most explicit attempt to establish an English opera season with the creation of the Royal National Opera at the St. James's Theatre [3], which opened on September 30, 1871. The aim was to stage a series of 40 performances of English opera and continental opera in English over five weeks. Sir Julius Benedict was to conduct some of his own operas [4].  The opening night had a mixed reception from the press [5] and after three weeks they left  the St James's [6] and decamped to the Standard where they stayed for five weeks. They again went to the Standard for a week at the end of the year. By mid January, they were in Cork and toured also to Limerick and Dublin, where the company disbanded on March 30, 1872.  December 26, 1871, saw Gilbert and Sullivan's first joint work, the opéra bouffe,Thespis.

In October 28, 1872, a company under Aynsley Cooke played a three week stint at the Standard Theatre but it must not have gone well as in the following January he was sued for unpaid wages by one of the soloists, George Perren, and the conductor, Sidney Naylor.  The Gaiety launched a short season in May 1873 and Charles Durand's company was at the Pavilion Theatre for two weeks in July 1873 and again early in 1874. Opéra bouffe in English was given at the Philharmonic Theatre in the autumn of 1874 and at the Alhambra in late 1874 and early 1875. 

Work began on James Mapleson's Grand National Opera House in September 1875. Mapleson intended that three or four months should be given over to English opera [7]. However, ill chosen ground meant that costs quickly escalated and the project was abandoned.  In the autumn of 1875, the Carl Rosa Company staged its first London season at the Princess's Theatre. Their repertoire was broader than other touring companies and included less well known works such as Cagnoni's The Porter of Havre and Cherubini's Les Deux Journées as well as, to the Sunday Times (Oct. 17, 1875) disgust, the "flimsy and trivial", "absolutely ridiculous", Balfe's The Siege of Rochelle.  1875 also saw English opera and continental opera in English at the Standard and the Philharmonic theatres and opera bouffe in English at the Alhambra and Gaiety theatres. The Graphic (Dec. 27, 1875) claimed that Rosa was going to open Drury Lane as an English Opera House. However, even if he had ever intended to do that, he must soon have realised what a drain a permanent theatre in London would be and confined himself to short seasons there. Except for D'Oyly Carte's short lived Royal English Opera House in 1891, there was no attempt to create an English opera house for the rest of the century.

In July 29, 1876, the Carl Rosa Company staged The Bohemian Girl at the Balfe Memorial Festival at Alexandra Palace and in the autumn, they played a season at the Lyceum Theatre, which included the premiere of Cowen's Pauline on November 22, the first major new English opera for ten years.

 

Outside of London

The Carl Rosa Company dominated the touring scene from September 1873 onwards eventually basing itself in Liverpool. However, there were many other companies both before it and contemporary with it.  In 1866, Pyne and Harrison did a short tour, the last together, although in 1867 Pyne took a small company, including her nieces, putting on one act operas/operettas in what was sometimes termed "Drawing Rooms Operetta Entertainment". They dispensed with scenery, no doubt partly to reduce costs and effort but also to be able to perform in unlicenced halls. Amongst the more durable companies, George Loveday's stands out. He was active from 1864 through to 1870, jointly with Oliver Summers from February 1867 to March 1869. The Yorkshire Herald (Feb. 28, 1870) was able to announce that it was the 400th week of "the present tour; the longest on record".  However, after an appearance in Maryport on September 28 and 29, 1870, Loveday seemed to have ceased to run an opera company, although he occasionally managed a troupe for someone else.  

Most of the company managers also sang in their productions, usually as the lead. The most notable included that of the baritone Charles Durand  who ran a tour every year throughout this period except for 1871, occasionally in partnership with other singers. Henry Corri had companies from 1866 up to the spring of 1872. Annie Thirlwall managed one from 1866 to 1868. For a short time Elliott Galer was joint manager with her until an accident and afterwards her husband's cousin, Henry Corri. In 1869, she sang with a company under the management of her husband, Eugene Corri.   Florence Lancia's company toured 1867  to early 1868, some of it in combination with Charles Durand. Edmund Rosenthal managed tours from 1866 through to 1869. Henry Cooper and Ann Milner resurrected the British Operatic Association from late 1869 to early 1871. Henry Haigh's company toured from late 1870 to 1876. Rose Hersee was a original member of the Carl Rosa Company but also organised a tour of her own in 1872. In 1874, George Perren took his Crystal Palace company on tour.

These tours covered not only the large British and Irish cities but many smaller towns.

[1] William Tyldesley, Michael William Balfe: his life and English operas. (Aldershot, UK: Ashgate Publishing, 2003), pp. 224-227 gives a short history.

[2] Sunday Times  (Oct.10, 1869). By this time the Crystal Palace had been relocated to South London

[3] The theatre was under the management of Mrs John Wood ( Matilda Vining), not to be confused with Mrs John Wood (Mary Ann Paton) who had died in 1864. Perren was one of the performers.  The manager was probably Stanley Dust.

[4] The prospectus was advertised in the Morning Post (Sep. 16, 1871)

[5] Lloyd's Weekly Newspaper (Oct 1, 1871) was encouraging and hopeful but the Graphic (Oct. 7, 1871) thought otherwise

[6] The Musical Times (Nov. 1, 1871), pp. 268 - 269. There were problems paying the orchestra's salaries

[7] Sunday Times (Sep. 12, 1875)